14 July 2021
Part of the RENK group, Horstman is a manufacturer and global supplier of suspension systems for heavily armoured and tracked vehicles. It also produces safety-critical engineering components allied to its core products for the sub-sea and aerospace industries. A transatlantic investment has seen the company advance its quality control procedures significantly by installing identical new coordinate measuring machines (CMMs) at its factories in Bath, UK and Sterling Heights, USA. Built by LK Metrology in Donington, UK, the new CMMs were supplied with the world’s most compact and versatile tactile scanning probe technology to capture data on the size and shape of components more accurately and much faster than was possible previously using touch trigger probing alone.
The factory at the company’s headquarters in Bath, which dates back to the 1920s when the original suspension bogie for military vehicles was developed, was an early adopter of CMMs in the 1960s when LK was one of the first to pioneer the measuring technology. Horstman has had a succession of different CMM models over the years, most recently three machines of small, medium and large capacity from a different supplier. The new LK Altera M 25.15.12 bridge CMM, which has a large inspection volume of nominally 2.5 x 1.5 x 1.2 metres and is equipped with traditional touch trigger probing and an advanced tactile scanning probe, replaced the smallest of the three earlier machines.
Trevor Prynne, Business Development Director at Horstman commented, “The contact scanning capability of the new LK CMMs acquires many hundreds of surface points every second, enabling interrogation of form as well as size and position, including of bores 400 mm deep.
“This latest investment in technology is in line with our desire to remain at the forefront of high precision, high integrity engineering, allowing us to continue to offer customers the guaranteed service in design and production that ensures serving soldiers have the best combination of armour, firepower and mobility they deserve.
“At Horstman, we are proud to supply products that exceed customer expectations. To do this we ensure that quality is not just a word that is spoken about during inspection of our components, but something that permeates throughout the whole group. All three of our locations, including the Canadian site in Ontario, have a minimum of ISO9001 accreditation, with the UK site also having AS9100 Rev D.”
Stephen Ellis, Quality Manager at the Bath factory added, “As we are involved in the supply of safety critical, defence related products, we decided that we needed a second large-capacity measuring machine that could inspect every size of component that we manufacture to provide redundancy in our capabilities if one of the CMMs should break down or require servicing. LK offered us the best package in terms of technology and accuracy of measurement at a mid-range price.
“We manufacture some components for our US factory and they produce others for us, so it was expedient to duplicate the metrology facility in our Sterling Heights plant. Crucially, LK is able to comprehensively support that installation as well, as it has a subsidiary in New Hudson, Michigan, just 40 miles away.”
He went on to say that LK provided a good training and support package in both locations, so the respective inspection teams either side of the Atlantic are able to prepare and share CMM programs seamlessly. The latest version of LK’s CAMIO 2021 software for programming and reporting has been supplied to the two factories. It may also be retrofitted to other CMMs on both sites in the future to enable interoperability between the different makes of CMM. CAMIO features a convenient graphical user interface, single and multi-part loading instructions, program queuing and advanced error recovery for automated inspection.
Within the Horstman group, new designs are being introduced with increasing regularity and to ever tighter tolerances for hydropneumatic suspensions, electronic and electro-hydraulic active vehicle ride management systems, military thermal management systems and the aerospace and sub-sea products. That is why the metrology departments were often under pressure and wanted to move quality control technology forward in terms of speed of data acquisition and the accuracy of the data collected, in particular for form measurement.
Component sizes are up to 1.15 metres in length by 0.75 metres in diameter. Materials include steel, titanium and aluminium and in addition to dimensions, shapes are captured rapidly and results are compared with the corresponding CAD model to ascertain fit and finish. Typical measurement cycle times are between 10 minutes and one hour. Features with a total tolerance down to 7 microns need to be inspected and some parts have reflective surfaces, which is why the manufacturer has not opted for the rapid, high density point cloud acquisition of laser scanning. It would entail surface preparation and in any case, laser sensors do not offer such high accuracy and repeatability as tactile probes, in Mr Ellis’s opinion.
The SP25M scanning probe comprises two sensors in a single housing. Users can switch between a choice of five scanning modules with styli lengths from 20 mm to 400 mm as well as modules compatible with Renishaw’s TP20 range of touch-trigger probes. This capability enables scanning and touch trigger probing in a single probe system. When using the scanning probe, the system can measure up to 1,000 points per second to deliver a very precise statement about deviations in profile and form that can affect product fit and function. Such high speed performance is partly due to improvements incorporated into the latest LK CMM controller. It signifies a major step forward in helping manufacturers to be competitive in today’s global market by reducing bottlenecks in the quality control department and cutting non-value-added inspection costs. Increased speed also enables metrology to keep pace with manufacturing and provide prompt feedback for adjusting production processes.
It is not only the LK controller and software that deliver superior tactile scanning capability. The stiffness of the CMM structure, with its ceramic beam and spindle, has optimal stiffness-to-weight ratio for high responsiveness and mechanical stability. Furthermore, LK’s single-orifice, grooved-face air bearings provide a smaller air gap with greater stiffness than standard air bearings to enhance rigidity. These attributes combine to suppress deflection of the machine structure during the repeated, rapidly accelerating and decelerating axis movements necessary for efficient continuous tactile scanning, especially on parts of complex geometry.
Three photographs attached:
1. The new LK Altera M 25.15.12 bridge CMM installed at the Bath factory of Horstman.
2. Horstman metrology engineer Martyn Hooper operating the LK CMM.
3. Another view of the LK CMM in use.
About LK Metrology
LK Metrology is renowned for innovative metrology solutions and services. The company’s products, including coordinate measuring machines (CMM), portable measuring arms and metrology software, are used worldwide to control and improve the quality of manufactured components. Its precision technology underpins the process chain from design, development, production and assembly through to quality assurance in global industries such as automotive, aerospace, defence, motorsport, energy, medical and contract inspection.
Established in England in 1963, LK Metrology has an impressive heritage in metrology dating back to the birth of CMM technology. Founded by CMM pioneer Norman Key and his father-in-law Jim Lowther, LK Metrology is credited with many of the CMM industry’s firsts including the first bridge-type design, first OEM to integrate computers, first to use a touch trigger probe, first to develop inspection software, first to use all air bearings and granite guideways, first to use carbon fibre composite spindles, first to use microprocessor-controlled drive systems, first to produce a truly thermally stable CMM and first to produce a high-accuracy horizontal-spindle CMM.
In 2018, LK Metrology was relaunched as an independent CMM manufacturer after several years as a division of Nikon Metrology. Headquartered in the UK, LK’s CMM development and production are at the company’s facility in Castle Donington. Sales and support offices are located in the UK, North America, Belgium, France, Germany, Italy and China, supplemented by a worldwide distributor network.
About Horstman
Horstman, a Company of the RENK group, is an agile and growing business comprising businesses units in the UK, US and Canada. Providing world leading design and manufacturing capabilities, our customers benefit from our time-tested pedigree in innovation, product development manufacture and defence project management in heavy armoured and tracked vehicle suspension systems.
Horstman led the world in the 1920’s with development of the independent suspension bogie that bears its name and the company’s influence features on tanks and wheeled vehicles to this day. With over a hundred highly skilled employees in the UK, US and Canada, we are a high value added, innovative engineering business with a global footprint in both customer base and supply chain. We provide a quality, technically excellent offering to solve customers’ problems, throughout the product life cycle.
The defence heavy armour business has arduous development and testing cycles to ensure that the serving soldier has the best combination of armour, firepower and mobility that they deserve. Horstman provides this balance to our customers – having built our talent base over decades from a combination of industry experts, service veterans and continuous investment in apprenticeships, graduates and training.